Brian’s Threaded Comments Plugin Reviewed
May 17th, 2007 by CourtCicero: We were born to unite with our fellow men, and to join in community with the human race.
This plugin ‘plugged’ a gaping hole in the ‘Make Money Online Free With Court’ ship. I wasn’t able to properly answer questions that were left in comments. This plugin makes it so that I can reply directly to a comment and have my reply show directly under the question - in the same box, in fact!
I don’t think that there is a better plugin for building a community. Yes, the ‘DoFollow‘ and ‘Top Commentators‘ plugins reward people for commenting, but that definitely doesn’t mean that you are building a sense of community. Helping people is what builds a sense of community, and you can do this by answering their questions! I can’t imagine a better way than using the plugin.
SEO Benefits
I know that usually when I review WordPress plugins I give my view from an SEO standpoint. With this plugin I don’t really see any positives and negatives except that fact that you are building a solid community, which will surely increase the amount of people that link to you. That is the one, although indirect positive.
How To Properly Use The Plugin
This plugin can’t achieve its purpose without added effort on your part. Use the plugin to answer people’s questions and to show them that you care. If you honestly care about helping your readers they will be able to tell. Reply to their comments, answer their questions, instruct, add to the discussion.
Installing The Plugin
Disclaimer: This plugin is fairly difficult and I wouldn’t go past this point if you don’t know how to manipulate HTML. Back everything up beforehand. Honestly, if you don’t back-up your theme’s files, you will wish you did. I obviously can’t take responsibility for you messing your site up and I provide this walk-through as-is and without warranty. I repeat: I will take no responsibility whatsoever if your site gets messed up! That said, this obviously worked for me. ![]()
- Go here and download the plugin.
- Extract the plugin. To do this you will right click your mouse and select ‘Extract, Extract All, or Extract Here’. (Any of the 3 will work)
- Upload the ‘briansthreadedcomments’ folder to your wp-content/plugins folder on your site’s server. Here’s a lesson on how to upload using FTP if you need it.
- Open up the folder that your theme is in and open up the comments.php file. Copy all of the contents and save them using notepad. You’re backing the file up in case you make a mistake somewhere! Even though I tell you to do this, some of you will skip this step and regret it.
- The plugin comes with a new comments.php file; you need to paste it into the folder of your theme, replacing the old comments.php. Don’t go messing with the first comments.php file you see! Make sure it’s the one in the folder of your current theme.
- Upload the new comments.php to wp-content/themes/*YourCurrentTheme*/
- Login to your WordPress admin, go to plugins, find ‘Brians Threaded Comments’ and click the ‘Activate’ link that is next to it.
- Voila! That’s it.
My Overall Thoughts On The Plugin
Everyone that hopes to get to the elite level should install it. It adds a lot of value to your site, if used properly. It won’t bring extra visitors to your site, but it will definitely help you to retain them.
Henry Ford: To do more for the world than the world does for you - that is success.
P.S. - I need to say thanks to Ryan Shamus who nominated me as one of the top 10 emerging, influential blogs of 2007.
Related Posts:
12 Ways To Get People Hooked On Your Site
1. Write pillar articles. One impressive post can make all the difference in the world. It could mea...
11 Unescapable Steps To WordPress Synergy
There's no longer a need to argue the benefits of using WordPress as your blogging platform. If you'...
My 15 Current Wordpress Plugins
A lot of people have been asking me lately about what plugins I'm using, so I have decided to post t...
WordPress Plugins
Here are all the plugins I'm using! For your convenience I will add the new plugins I install at the...
‘Show Top Commentators’ Plugin Reviewed
Last week I reviewed a popular WordPress plugin called the 'Ultimate Tag Warrior'. The response was ...
What’s Wrong With This Picture?
The problem with this picture is that 17 of the 18 comments were from the same spammer. Sinc...

May 17th, 2007 at 11:50 am
“It won’t bring extra visitors to your site, but it will definitely help you to retain them.”
Totally agreed. It makes reading answering comment so much easier. Thanks for the review.
May 17th, 2007 at 2:03 pm
It definitely makes my life a lot easier, it’s about 100 times easier to answer people’s questions.
May 17th, 2007 at 5:29 pm
Most certainly, I’m adding this one to the site as soon as I can.
August 7th, 2007 at 2:25 pm
[…] Install the Brian’s Threaded Comments plugin (Sorry, WordPress blogs only!). This allows you to answer your readers questions directly. […]
August 7th, 2007 at 3:29 pm
Thanks for sharing this plugin. I’m definitely going to try it out!
August 7th, 2007 at 4:23 pm
unfortunately it does not work with my theme.
It’s an all-white background that clashes with the rest of the blog. I’m sure there is a way to edit it but I don’t have time to play with php. lol
January 4th, 2008 at 3:06 am
It worked like a charm!!!
Grazie!
February 26th, 2008 at 10:33 am
Thanks a lot for this information, that what i was looking for to do in my blog but, I didn’t know what was the term for it. Well now i know and thanks for the tips.
March 31st, 2008 at 5:29 pm
Hi
Wasjust serfing on net and found this site…want to say thanks. Great site and content!
May 13th, 2008 at 4:25 am
8 32 Threaded…
Good post by Courtneytuttle. His view on 8 32 threaded is ……
August 27th, 2008 at 3:10 pm
Just one question. i know you went through a lot of trouble writing your disclaimer on this post, but I’m wondering if all this could be avoided by using the Pluginstaller (http://henning.imaginemore.de/pluginstaller) plugin.
Thanks