10 Comments

Case Study - SEO Meter

January 29th, 2008 by Court

 

Ok guys it’s time to take a look at an online business to evaluate what they’re doing right, and what they’re doing wrong. I love having the opportunity to do these evaluations because it gives us something practical to discuss. Being featured in this type of study on Court’s Internet Marketing School is a paid service, but has nothing to do with the ridiculous paid reviews that other sites are doing. These evaluations are intended to expose critical errors, give good ideas for your sites, and praise what’s being done correctly.

SEO Meter Takes Care Of A Need

When Google is evaluating your site, they will use a lot of different factors to determine where to rank it. Getting Google to crawl your site often is a huge step in achieving good rankings, especially if your site reports any type of news. When news breaks, you want be able to write about it quickly - and you need Google to find it almost instantly.

A perfect example of this is when I first wrote a post about Izea RealRank. The post was indexed instantly, and it turned out I was one of the first to write about this concept. You will still find me on the first page of Google for multiple ways people search for this:

  • Realrank
  • Izea RealRank
  • Real Rank
  • Izea Real Rank

Since I was one of the first to write about this subject, I became an instant authority on the matter. Google has kept me as an authority on RealRank ever since, and this has resulted in steady traffic from people seeking information about it.

Now this wouldn’t have been possible if Google didn’t crawl my site frequently. When I publish a post, I get almost instant indexing, almost every time. This helps me because if any news ever breaks, I can get indexed before many other sites that write about it.

Ok now assuming that you need to know how often Google crawls your site, how do you test that crawl rate? That’s where SEO Meter comes into play. Once you add your site to SEO Meter, they will determine your crawl rate and keep track of results. You can go back and check these results as often as you would like.

Brandability

SEO Meter is a brilliant name for a brand and I can see this site growing into a very valuable service. I do have some ideas to make this better, and I will discuss those later. The first thing I noticed when I went to the site was the logo, which you should all take a look at. There’s no doubt that the SEO Meter logo was done by a professional and it gives the site a very professional feel. I’m not going to show a picture here because you should all have a look at the site anyway. I’m considering upgrading both the web design and logo of my site, because you need a professional look to have a flagship site.

This is the kind of site that I would love to start. It has a good idea, feels a need, and is very brandable.

Things I Would Change

Ok the first thing I would do is upgrade the method used to determine Google’s crawl rate. Right now the site is using Google’s cache to determine this, and the results aren’t going to be entirely accurate that way. I would keep the existing tool and would label it as a Google cache rate tool, and would then create a new tool altogether.

The new tool would be harder to build, but would still be pretty straightforward. I would use the Statcounter approach, giving people a script or a file to place on their site. They would then come back to SEO Meter to log in and check the results. This would be a lot more accurate method to test the rate and would bring more repeat traffic back to SEO Meter.

Right now I can tell you that Google comes to my site hundreds of times each day but only caches the site once or twice. I’m a lot more interested in the crawl rate than I am in the rate Google is caching my pages.

In my opinion, making this change would make the site more useful and would make it easier to write about it. If the site made the change, I would write about it for free (that’s an open invitation) because I would see it as a service that everyone should use.

 

Related Posts:
Saturday Case Study - HowToMobile.com (Week 5)
...
Saturday Case Study - HowToMobile.com Case Study (Week 4)
...
Saturday Case Study - HowToMobile.com (Week 6)
...
#1 Ranking - What’s Next?
...
Saturday Theme - New Website Case Study
...
How Difficult Are Your Keywords?
...

RSS feed | Trackback URI

10 comments! »

MyAvatars 0.2

January 29th, 2008 at 1:33 pm

Hey Court,

Good evaluation. Some people do not understand the difference between caching and crawling.

I have one blog that I haven’t posted to in about 3 months. Just recently I started posting again.

My Google Webmaster account says it hasn’t been “visited” since Oct. However, some of the recent post show up in the Serps.

I agree with you, I wish Site Meter would change the name and come out with a tool that told us the actual times our sites were crawled. I’d sign up for that service!

Comment by Court
MyAvatars 0.2

January 29th, 2008 at 2:59 pm

Yeah I’ve actually noticed the same thing Don. The ‘visits’ that it talks about in webmaster tools is actually just the ‘cache’ of the homepage usually.

If they made the change, I would totally use it all the time. :)

 
Comment by Robert
MyAvatars 0.2

January 30th, 2008 at 1:23 am

It’s also important to note that the information in Google Webmaster Tools tends to be several days or weeks behind reality, too. It’s useful for some things, but seeing where you stand has too much of a lag. Doing actual searches is a whole lot more current. :)

 
 
Comment by Chris Subscribed to comments via email
MyAvatars 0.2

January 29th, 2008 at 1:53 pm

Nicely done. Question though: there is a difference between cached and crawled, what would the importance be for being cached as crawled should definitely be the main factor?

Comment by Court
MyAvatars 0.2

January 29th, 2008 at 3:01 pm

Well being cached quickly shows that you have trust from Google Chris. This post, for example, is already cached - that usually means that Google trusts your site as a place of valuable content.

You have to have the crawling in order to get cached quickly.

 
 
Comment by Jason A Clark
MyAvatars 0.2

January 29th, 2008 at 3:54 pm

I could definitely see this as being a useful tool. Your suggested tool would be the better solution, though. Something for SEO Meter to think about.

 
Comment by Vaibhav Subscribed to comments via email
MyAvatars 0.2

January 30th, 2008 at 3:42 am

Hi Court,

Very well you have given the information in your content to understand the difference between caching and crawling.

I have lot’s of blog for my current call center site. ANd I am doing the updation on daily basis.

This time I have seen the site meter, I hope I will get good information from it.

Thanks once again.

 
Comment by phantompain Subscribed to comments via email
MyAvatars 0.2

January 30th, 2008 at 5:03 am

it’s not so easy to have a script on the website to evaluate crawl rate, this can not be a javascript that could simply be embeded into html, this should be a server-side script (like php or asp) and it should lets SEOMeter service know every time google crawls this or that page (this could be done via http request) however a lot of hosting providers disallow fetching remote files so in order to do a flexible algorithm - guys should think hard :) And of course inserting third-party server-side script also is a major security issue so not everybody will consider this.

 
Comment by Default Layouts
MyAvatars 0.2

February 3rd, 2008 at 3:36 pm

I wish my blog was this successful.

 
Comment by Horse Handicapping
MyAvatars 0.2

February 8th, 2008 at 6:44 pm

Hmm, another SEO tool that I haven’t ever checked out… time to do some research of my own! Thanks

 

What do you think? Join the discussion...

Name (required)
E-mail (required - never shown publicly)
Website
Your Comment (smaller size | larger size)